Glass Shower Doors vs Shower Curtains: Which is the Better Option for Your Bathroom?

Choosing between glass shower doors and shower curtains can be a tough decision when you’re looking to remodel your shower. Both options have their own set of advantages and disadvantages, and it’s important to consider factors such as aesthetics, functionality, maintenance, and cost before making a decision.

Glass Shower Doors

Glass shower doors are most common in walk-in showers, offering a somewhat seamless entrance into your shower. Many choose doors for a shower to avoid picking out a shower curtain or to open up a small space.

Pros of a Shower Door:

  • Aesthetics: One of the biggest advantages of shower doors is the sleek and modern look they can add to a bathroom. Glass doors can create an open and airy feel, making the bathroom appear more spacious and luxurious.
  • Visibility: Clear glass doors provide an unobstructed view of the shower area, which can be visually appealing and make the bathroom feel more open.
  • Durability: Glass doors are known for their durability and resistance to wear and tear, making them a long-lasting investment.
  • Easy Maintenance: Easy to clean and maintain, glass doors come with fewer risks of mold or mildew buildup compared to shower curtains.
  • Water Containment: Glass doors effectively contain water within the shower area, reducing the chances of water leakage and preventing a wet bathroom floor.

Cons of a Shower Door:

  • Installation Cost: The initial installation cost of shower doors can be higher compared to shower curtains, which may not be feasible for some homeowners.
  • Limited Privacy: Bathrooms with clear glass doors may not provide enough privacy for some individuals.
  • Vulnerability to Breakage: Glass doors can be a safety concern if they break or shatter, which can happen due to various reasons such as improper installation or accidental impact.
  • Potential Hard Water Stains: Hard water stains can be a common issue with glass doors, requiring regular cleaning and maintenance.
  • Limited Design Options: The design options for glass doors might be more limited compared to shower curtains, which can limit customization options for the bathroom.

Ultimately, there are equal pros and cons to installing a glass shower door. While a glass door may work for some, it may not be the best option for those looking to customize their bathroom with a shower curtain or in need of more privacy.

Shower Curtains

A shower curtain rod is a simple installation during your bath remodel and gives you the option to pick out the shower curtain you want, adhering to your bathroom’s style. Just like a glass door, a shower curtain might work great for some and not so much for others.

Pros of a Shower Curtain:

  • Affordability: Shower curtains are generally more affordable compared to shower glass doors, making them a budget-friendly option.
  • Easy Installation: Shower curtains are easy to install and replace without the need for professional assistance, making them a convenient choice for homeowners.
  • Design Versatility: Shower curtains come in a wide range of design options, allowing for easy customization to match any bathroom décor.
  • Privacy: Opaque or patterned shower curtains can provide increased privacy in the bathroom.
  • Easy Replacement: Shower curtains can be easily replaced or updated to refresh the bathroom’s look, without the need for extensive renovation.

Cons of a Shower Curtain:

  • Maintenance Challenges: Shower curtains are susceptible to mold or mildew buildup, requiring regular cleaning and periodic replacements.
  • Water Leakage: Shower curtains may not effectively contain water within the shower area, potentially causing a wet bathroom floor.
  • Limited Lifespan: Shower curtains have a shorter lifespan compared to shower glass doors and may need more frequent replacements.
  • Visual Obstruction: Shower curtains can obstruct light and make the bathroom appear smaller or darker, which may not be ideal for some homeowners.

Choosing between glass doors and shower curtains ultimately comes down to individual preferences, budget, maintenance requirements, and bathroom design. Both options have their own set of advantages and disadvantages, and it’s important to weigh the factors to make an informed decision. Whether you choose shower doors for a sleek and modern look or shower curtains for affordability and design versatility, the key is to create a functional and aesthetically pleasing bathroom shower that meets your needs and preferences.


West Shore Home® offers both shower curtain rod and shower door options when you remodel with us. Plus, we’ll get your new shower installed in as little as one day so you can enjoy it as soon as possible. We recommend scheduling a consultation with a shower expert to learn more about your options with your remodel project. Contact us today to get started!