How to Replace an Exterior Door: Key Considerations for Homeowners

July 9, 2024

Replacing an exterior door can significantly improve your home’s comfort, security, and curb appeal. Whether you’re seeking enhanced energy efficiency, better security, or a fresh style, upgrading your door can add considerable value to your property. Here’s a comprehensive guide on how to replace an exterior door, covering all the critical factors to ensure a successful project.

Understanding the Reasons for Replacement

The first step in replacing an exterior door is to understand why you want to replace it. This will guide all your subsequent decisions. Homeowners typically replace their doors for three main reasons:

  • Energy Efficiency: Modern doors with advanced materials and seals can prevent air leaks, reducing energy costs.
  • Security: Older doors with worn-out materials like hinges and seals can be vulnerable to security threats. Newer doors are usually sturdier and provide better protection.
  • Style: A new door can refresh your home’s look, adding modern features such as sidelights, transoms, or integrated windows.

3D Render Showing Door Security & Energy Efficiency Features

Benefits of Knowing Your Why:

  • Tailors your choices to meet specific needs
  • Ensures a focused and efficient replacement process
  • Helps in setting realistic expectations and goals

Setting Your Budget

Knowing your budget is crucial as it directly impacts the scope of your project. Considerations like design, materials, and additional features will depend on how much you are willing to spend.

A piggy bank next to a stack of coins.

Budget Considerations:

  • Material Costs: Different materials have varying prices.
  • Design and Style: Custom or high-end designs will cost more.
  • Installation: Decide whether you will DIY or hire a professional, as this affects overall costs.

Tips for Budget Planning:

  • Set a realistic budget early in the planning phase.
  • Stick to your budget to avoid unnecessary expenses.
  • Allocate funds for unforeseen expenses.

Choosing Styles, Materials, and Features

Once a budget has been established, you can focus on the scope and scale of your project. This will involve questions including what materials to consider, what styles are in the conversation, and what features you can splurge for.

A series of exterior home entryways.

You can then start selecting the style, material, and features of your new door. Here are some options:

Styles:

  • Modern
  • Farmhouse
  • Craftsman
  • Traditional
  • Custom designs

Materials:

  • Steel
  • Fiberglass
  • Wood
  • Aluminum
  • Vinyl

Core Features:

  • Quality hinges, locks, and doorknobs
  • Seals and weather stripping
  • Integrated windows or sidelights

Additional Features:

  • Door coatings or paints
  • Integrated security systems
  • Extra hardware like slide hatches

Key Considerations:

    • Match the door style with your home’s architecture.
    • Choose durable and weather-resistant materials.
    • Consider energy-efficient features.

Deciding Between DIY and Hiring a Professional

Now that you’ve figured out why you’re replacing your door, what your budget is, and what materials and styles you’d like to go for, you can decide if you have the skills to execute it or if you need a professional. 

An infographic depicting both professional and D.I.Y. home remodeling efforts.

Determine if you have the skills and tools to replace the door yourself or if you need to hire a professional. Each option has its pros and cons.

DIY

  • Pros:
    • Full control over project timeline
    • Flexibility in choosing materials and suppliers
    • Potential cost savings
  • Cons:
    • No professional warranties
    • Risk of errors without professional expertise

Hiring a Professional

  • Pros:
    • Expertise and experience ensure a quality installation
    • Access to warranties and service agreements
    • Often faster completion with less personal effort
  • Cons:
    • Higher initial cost
    • Limited control over some aspects of the project

Steps for Replacing an Exterior Door

  1. Measure Your Existing Door:
    • Accurately measure the height, width, and thickness of your current door.
  2. Select Your New Door:
    • Choose the style, material, and features based on your budget and preferences.
  3. Prepare the Door Frame:
    • Ensure the frame is level and in good condition. Repair any damage before installation.
  4. Install the New Door:
    • Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for proper installation.
    • Ensure the door is aligned and operates smoothly.
  5. Finish and Seal:
    • Apply weather stripping and caulk to seal gaps and improve energy efficiency.

DIY Tips:

  • Use high-quality tools and materials.
  • Double-check measurements to avoid fitting issues.
  • Follow safety protocols to prevent accidents.

Moving Forward with Your Exterior Door Replacement

To recap, here are the core considerations for your exterior door replacement project:

  • Understand why you are replacing your door.
  • Set and adhere to a realistic budget.
  • Choose styles, materials, and features that fit your needs.
  • Decide whether to DIY or hire a professional.

Choosing the professional route? West Shore Home offers top-notch door replacement and installation services, featuring a wide variety of styles, quality materials, and a lifetime warranty. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and transform your home with a new exterior door.